At the end of last month, I broke out my copy of Wacht am Rhein again to try a more maneuverable scenario: Ride of the Valkyries. It showed pretty effectively why the 1st SS Panzer Division had a better time advancing at the start of the German offensive than the 12th SS Panzer Division.
Dec 16:
Four German divisions move to contact with the 2nd and 99th Infantry Divisions, targeting weak points along a 23-mile front. Von der Heydte successfully drops behind the US line. Three Volksgrendier Divisions and the 3rd Fallschirmjaeger Division, supported by a massing of 6th Panzer Army artillery, try to hem in the two US infantry divisions at Elsenborn, to allow the 2 SS panzer divisions to try and execute a pincer movement around them. By noon, progress is mixed. The 3rd Fallschirmjaeger and 12th Volksgrenadier divisions punch through the 99th Division's south flank while the remaining two Volksgrenadier divisions fail to press forward on the entrenched Americans.
As the day wears on, the Americans slowly begin to respond, and as the 99th's south flank begins to unravel, Otto Skorzeny's Einheit Stielau units begin to eliminate forward units and slip through the American lines. A few of the units are captured behind enemy lines but most make it through. Then the 1st and 12th SS Panzer divisions are released. The 1st SS, led by KG Peiper, moves to exploit the gap created by the 3rd Fallschirmjaeger division is opposed only by the 99th Division's HQ position at Bullingen. For the 12th SS, the road west is blocked by the 2nd Infantry Division.
Dec 17:
With the Germans punching through north and south, the 2nd and 99th infantry divisions form a protective ring around Elsenborn ridge and the town of Elsenborn. Elements of the 5th and 7th armored divisions arrive from farther north along the line to block the advance of the 12th SS Panzer Division. The 12th finds its path of advance blocked, but the 1st SS presses west.
With additional support, the 277th and 12th Volksgrenadier divisions start to push back the remainder of the 99th Infantry division, turning their pressure north, widening the corridor for Peiper's advance. Otto Skorzeny's troops successfully delay the arrival of US armor in Monschau, allowing the 12th SS to secure the town after finally breaking through the 2nd Infantry Division's road blocks and piecing the thin reserve line held by cavalry recon forces.
12th SS puts pressure on the armored forces of the 5th and 7th US armored divisions outside of Mutzenich and the 1st SS hammers the mixed corps and 1st US Army units in the region of Malmedy, south of the Ambleve river.
As the Germans continue their advance throughout the day, the panzer forces manage to isolate and eliminate straggling forces, mostly from the 99th infantry. As night nears, the 2nd and 99th are in danger of being completely surrounded. With the Germans slowly pressing forward on their front, both US divisions begin a general withdrawal west. Outer defenses move back to Elsenborn.
Luckily for the 2nd and 99th, additional infantry forces arrive to relieve some pressure. Elements of the 9th Infantry Division link up with the elements of 5th armor, and move to block the 12th SS. Farther south, elements of the 1st and 30th infantry divisions race to oppose the 1st SS Panzer Division's advance.
Von Der Heyde's company, still holding the Eupen-Malmedy road, is finally dislodged by the 2/47 infantry regiment and is forced to towards the positions of the 12th SS Panzer Division.
Advance elements of the 150th Panzer Brigade meanwhile attack the HQ positions of the 2nd US Infantry as it pulls back outside of Elsenborn. Luckily, thanks to the onset of darkness, the panzers are unable to press an initial breakthrough, and are prevented from completely overrunning the divisional HQ.
Dec 18:
The 1st SS Panzer Division continues its advance west, and the US corps and army forces race to place blocking forces near Tros Ponts. In the process of racing to block Peiper (whose heavy armor is held up by the M10 tank destroyers and infantry of the 1st Infantry Division outside of Malmedy), the Americans leave Stavelot undefended, finally providing the Germans with safe passage over the Warche river. The result is disastrous, and Peiper capitalizes on the sudden momentum, forcing a crossing at Malmedy, leaving the GIs of the 1st US infantry almost completely surrounded and the 1st SS division within reach of the US rear area.
.jpg)








